I recently previewed Discovering Emma, and found myself surprisingly educated. I’m not a history buff; I’ve heard insinuations that Emma Smith and Brigham Young didn’t get along, and that’s about it. So in watching this, I was amazed at what I learned.
I don’t want to spoil it for anyone, but the interviews with the historians and scholars (Susan Easton Black, Gracia Jones, and Paul Smith) brought up information like how Joseph and Emma found they’d been betrayed, which led to the martyrdom. Now many of you probably knew this already, but again, I’ve never delved into the history behind the restoration beyond what was directly connected to the gospel. So think about it: if you’d been betrayed and your husband killed, would you really want to travel out west, possibly with others who mean you harm?
I did always think it was odd that Emma didn’t go west. But the perspective given by these scholars made me see a lot of reasons why she didn’t and why she might have if circumstances had been different. It answers questions about why the RLDS Church was started—and while the scholars assume you know a little bit about it, I was still able to fill in the blanks and understand why that church came about, and learn about Emma’s association with it.
There is Emma’s second marriage to Lewis Bidamon, and the scholars again brought up information that I’d never heard about—some of it answering controversy that I’m sure exists if you’re in the historian circle. I think what I got the most from this DVD was that you can never know and judge a person until you’ve walked in his or her shoes. And Emma walked far, with lots of trials that would break most people. I admire the respect with which each scholar addressed the questions and the respect they each have for Emma. Please share your thoughts as well once you’ve seen Discovering Emma.